An unofficial community about Apple and all of its devices and software. News. The echo studio will have more base, while the HomePod will have more clarity. The beam has good near field low end but just isn’t as good in a larger room, the HomePod gives you good low end and dual HomePods give you nice stereo separation. Reply reply. Personally I would go with the HomePod, but I understand that you may want to go with the echo studio for other reasons. More responsive yes. HomePod delivers Apple Music support, which means it supports voice control, but it supports all streaming over AirPlay. Also HKSV stopped recording a few time when the HomePod mini took over. HomePod (2. Nest audio sounds a bit better in my experience. HomePod Mini + Roam 2 // vs // HomePod Mini + Amp Setup. Interesting Tech News It should be remembered, however, that any iOS device with up-to-date software can stream to a HomePod. u/Person1325. HomePod Mini has a subwoofer and a noise So an Apple TV (4th Gen and above) or any HomePod version can be the Home hub. 9 inches wide and 3. During our brief encounter, the HomePod sounded the best and was the most consistent. Both are good. I’d also say avoid the HomePod if you don’t use Apple music. I find Alexa faster and more reliable than Siri. Better quality sound but like others stated, Siri is a I really like Sonos. Share. It was cheaper and newer. It may be mini, but the HomePod mini delivers room-filling sound on-demand using just your voice. No he didn't actually compare it to his $90k reference system. 1 system, a good Klipsch subwoofer. It’s also less intrusive on the privacy front. 2. Works over LAN. Especially when I was on iOS 13 the HomePod was solid and when my Apple TV would be flaky with my Ecobee Gen 5. I had a HomePod mini, but took it back in favor of a Sonos One. The Google Nest Audio and the Apple HomePod mini are very similar speakers overall. Sonos Play:5 Gen 2. However, the Apple speaker uses Siri and May 19, 2022 · The prices of Amazon Echo smart speakers start at $49. The Apple comes with Siri built-in, while the Google features Google Assistant. If you are not having any issues, I would not change. The original HomePod is definitely more bass heavy, but I’ve always complained about this since it was launched. The Google comes with Google Assistant built-in and offers bass and treble adjustments so you can customize its sound profile to your liking. If you're deep in the Google ecosystem and use Google's own services for music, the Home Max won't disappoint. Mainly I want to be able to tell a speaker to find my phone (make it ring), call someone, text someone, play music or podcast on Spotify, READ TEXTS, Shazam music, lmk when someone is calling me, find restaurants, give directions to my phone/google maps, ANNOUNCE EVENTS IN my (GOOGLE Edit: if you are talking abt the hpmini then sonos roam is a better choice. The resultant graph shows the near-perfectly flat frequency response of the HomePod. They also integrate much better with Apple stuff; the HomePod/Apple TV integration is amazing. Google Home just made lots of improvements on 3rd party cameras and devices. if so one by one reboot the other homekit hubs. Stereo, amp, speakers blow it all away. Middle-Holiday9449. Even after tweaking in the Sonos app Which of these is going to have better audio quality? Related Topics HomePod Apple Inc. • 2 yr. I’m still happy with upgrade, but Apple needs to spend more time on quality software. I have a mix of the OG HomePods and Minis. Mini sounds the most balanced, but Echo ($99) has the best compatibility and can get louder and has the more base. More reliable, sadly not entirely. A User community for smart speakers and displays from Google Home/Nest and their related products that… If your primary use case is audio, the OG HomePod is simply the best - better than even the Sonos ones. Action movies are just plain more fun that way. Also the HomePod delivers a lot of sound for its size and the microphones seem to work better than on all the echos I had. But HomeKit is lovely in general, very easy overall. HomePods sound better than Google Home devices. I am a heavily invested in the apple ecosystem, and all smart home tech I bought (excluding nest cameras and nest thermostat) are HomeKit compatible. Google homes are more accurate and give better answers than any echo has. Even the symfonisk is an improvement in my opinion. Depends what you want to do. 1 music is better. Apple’s privacy record is far from perfect, but nowhere near as terrible as Amazon or Google. Most importantly works with all of your devices. Soundbar has the left and right channels packed in one box. I find HomeKit far more intuitive and easy to use than either Amazon or Google. 0. Some will say the Apple TV wired to Ethernet is the best option. The smallest I personally prefer the Google Assistant, but Alexa is a strong voice option. The HomePod Mini is $134. If you want your music to stop every few hours, get the Nest Audio. • HomePod Software 18. Not just sales of the Mini, but used sales of the original HomePod. You only have to be on the same Wifi network. It’s just frustratingly dumb and we only trust it/bother with it for a handful of commands that we know will work. Google, meanwhile, offers more freedom — its Jan 10, 2020 · The Echo Plus (2nd gen) has a hub built-in for smart home devices and costs £139 / $179. 7M subscribers in the Android community. It takes three minutes. GoodwithTools2023. no voice assistant support (Alexa Or Google Home supported but you have to buy them separately) more expensive. The echo is going to be way better at being a smart speaker and will be cheaper. you can pair the HPM and the sonos devices using airplay 2 to get the best of both worlds. They think it is a rip-off pricewise because they don't understand the sound quality and are comparing it to Amazon echo or regular google home because most don't even know about the Google max. That said I do not use any automation inside their ecosystems. Then there is the regular Echo (3rd gen) for £89 / $99, which is similar to the Google Home. In stereo mode. Apr 4, 2019 · The HomePod and Google Home Max are both capable, powerful smart speakers that'll cost you a pretty penny (the Google Home Max costs $100 more). Apple HomeKit is the better way to go. Same conclusion. Edit: someone pointed out that ipads can no longer be used as hubs. Sonos supports true surround sound and has a physical center channel. If the one without Thread is the active hub all is fine. Google Home is moderately better. The original HomePod’s main weakness was its high price point. It also supports Chromecast. I'm considering ditching Google Nest devices (Google Nest Hub Max and Google Nest Minis) and replacing them with HomePods. I have tried uninstalling and reinstalling Home but nothing changes. I'd never leave the apple ecosystem though, especially not for amazon or google. 1M subscribers in the GooglePixel community. The reduced Wi-Fi speeds make a huge difference with cameras in a HomeKit setup and I noticed automations not being reliable. That said, neither of them are going to do a great job of integrating directly with Apple stuff. HomePod 2: A Definitive Audiophile Review. I have a HomePod mini and I can control everything well and it’s quite stable - but the They say to click settings and then remove a device, but there's no remove a device in settings. I like sound of the HomePod more. Nest is not bad but HomePod really separates out the sound. I'm already heavily invested in Apple ecosystem. HomePod as a hub has always been rock solid and I prefer over an Apple TV even while my Apple TV are hardwired. 1. In my experience, just the 2 front stereo pair sounds better. Coming from an Amazon echo system, HomePods all the way. Apple HomePod vs Sonos. HomePods can only get so loud. My logic was, the OG HomePod can't possibly sound so much better it justifies the x3 price in Canada. Just bring your iPhone near and the music / call will transfer. The only disadvantage is you cannot control it with your voice. Get support, learn new… Jul 23, 2020 · The Sonos One is $199, while the Apple HomePod is $299. Besides the price, both take slightly different approaches to what a smart speaker should be, and thus, the final products differ in some significant ways. One 100 is good enough for that use case. Apple’s HomePod 2 is considerably more expensive than the Sonos One, coming in at £299 / $299 / AU$479. Sonos supports Airplay 2, Google Home, and Alexa. It sounds great, but can't quite match the quality we heard from its Apple competitor. But if the lights are an added plus go for it. I have yet to see a profile released yet, but hopefully it gets released later today. The separation of the L/R and the sound stage will be hugely limited to physical size of the bar itself. In fact, you ask your HomePod to play music live from Apple Music / Spotify OR to stream from your iPhone with AirPlay. Yeah, the unfortunate truth about HPMs is that you need at least two for even decent sound. The Google ecosystem works with 10,000 smart robsaskibum. I recently upgraded the “. For something on your desk an Era 300 is absolutely overkill. 0" model. 3 inches tall Replacing Google Nest with HomePod. Mini was at 78dcb. For the Google Nest Audio, $99 is a fair price Jul 12, 2023 · HomeKit is tightly regulated by Apple, which allows it to offer a streamlined experience that works flawlessly with all products in its catalog. 8M subscribers in the apple community. The Beam sounds great, but the HomePods just fill the room with more sound. • 6 yr. 81 votes, 22 comments. That being said, 2x HomePod is much better than 1x HomePod. From the two you listed I would lean towards the HomePod. . HomePod in 2. Aug 19, 2023 · The Google Nest Mini and the Apple HomePod Mini are both competitive micro smart speakers that act as smart home control hubs. The serious alternative is Home Assistant. Currently I do not have a HomePod 2 17 votes, 13 comments. Feb 26, 2024 · The Google Home Max and the Apple HomePod (1st generation) are two speakers with a voice assistant built-in, and you may prefer one over the other. Hands down. no line in. I noticed right away that the Era 300s lack full mid to low bass. Yes he makes a much more sensible comparison to the Klipsch "The Three. When it comes to the key differences between Apple HomePod Mini and Google Nest Audio, the HomePod Mini has a slightly better performance in terms of design, connectivity, and features. In terms of price in my city, the HomePod is $270, and Bose $427 (at full price) and $342 when on discount. You may need to get an access point like this. So it’s better for movies. General discussion about… There is no comparison. So HomePod’s compatibility with Spotify is a major concern. Anything relevant to living or working in Japan such as lifestyle, food, style, environment, education, technology, housing, work, immigration, sport etc. The HomePod mini is the smart speaker for Apple fans thanks to its seamless integration with iOS, Apple TV, and HomeKit. I run the CD player via coax and the AEX via Toslink to the Modi. Nest Mini. The only maybe upside of the hp is that it can act as a hkhub, but considering that you already are really deep in the apple ecosystem, you probably have an ipad/atv doing that. ly/HomeKitDiscord. $99. Depends who you trust the most to be listening in your home. This is doubly true on HomePod because Siri can actually handle even less on HomePod than it can on an iPhone or iPad. $49. The issue I have with the mini’s and newer HomePod OG sized is the Wi-Fi chip is Wi-Fi 4 standards or 802. However: Siri is terrible. HomePod minis in an apartment is perfect, they’re beasts, best for their size no question. Here is that graph, note that it's had 1/12 smoothing applied to it, in order to make it easier to read. at Best Buy. However siri will not be better on any homepod at all, it’s going to be the ole dumb siri we all know and hate lmao. ago. Google Nest Audio. As others have said, Home Assistant is what you want. With two YMMV. 31. (Image credit: Apple) Like the original HomePod, the HomePod (2nd gen) costs $299, which makes it more expensive than competing smart speakers arbroremustafa. For a bedroom tv I thought the regular echo was the perfect size in a stereo pair but HomePods just have 2 sizes and neither are in that medium size category meaning you can either go with HomePod regulars or minis. Android news, reviews, tips, and discussions about rooting, tutorials, and apps. Some of our Aqara buttons don't work when the HomePod mini takes over. You can hear the sound separation crispy clear. Now with iOS 14 my Apple TV as the hub has been rock solid to this point. Gen) - Side-by-side comparison of the internals. The Sonos pair also sounds more balanced to me, whereas the HomePod sounds too bass heavy. Down the road you can add speakers to it that would make the system blow HomePods out of the water. At first I bought the HomePod mini. If you don’t need the Thread support or the UWB functionality, then buy a used 1st Gen. Echo Dot is the worst in terms of sound quality. This is my setup: As you can see my kitchen HomePod mini is my current hub and has been that way since the last beta that came out. Apple chose the first two and sacrificed loudness. • 1 yr. 5mm line in. Better Home app structure, view of your products and better automations. That shit is loud enough to fill a large living room. While I’ve had fewer ungluing, I’ve had a few cases where one of the pair (or both) becomes unresponsive and needs rebooting. Fck, my HomePod responded before the one in the video. I am debating between Google Nest vs. Another testament to this incredible speaker’s ability to be true to any recording. Like the Nest Mini, the HomePod Mini is also fabric-wrapped, and it measures 3. • 4 yr. Try listening to a great mono recording with standard speakers, then listen to the same recording on a single HomePod. A device I moved into a different room suddenly moved back into the original room when the HomePod mini took over. Aug 22, 2022 · The Nest Mini is half the price of the HomePod Mini, and it goes on sale frequently. Siri is legit awful comparatively. I got the HomePod mini and within a day returned it. uhohmomspaghetti • 7 mo. My requirements: the system can be controlled via my indoor HomePod mini. In my opinion the google home stuff works much better than Alexa. The (un)official home of #teampixel and the #madebygoogle lineup on Reddit. (Not to be the um, actually guy, but iPads are no longer supported as home hubs) Oct 13, 2020 · Apple HomePod mini is more expensive. In the end, however, I returned the One for another Homepod. supports a wide range of streaming services. Apple HomePod mini. That’s Spotify, not Apple, making that experience terrible. Siri is the choice if you are locked into the Apple ecosystem. 0/2. Era 300's are just ok as stereo pair, and really shine w/ Atmos/spatial audio. Nasdaq, s&p, emerging markets, small cap. I have a few Google Home Minis spread around the house to control everything and I’m almost to the point to switch to Apple. We’ll get into why there’s a hundred-dollar price difference later in this comparison, and once you’ve had a chance to digest the The HomePod is known to be bassy. If you’re deep in the Apple ecosystem and value audio quality, yes. MountainWise587. Both AIs are better than Siri though. ago • Edited 8 mo. Gen) vs. Apple is currently only offering one smart speaker after discontinuing its original HomePod in Overall, the HomePod sounded vibrant, rich, and balanced. for me the best solution is HELLO, a device which is provided by Solaborate, it works both with Google Home and Amazon Alexa, provides a hands-free control with your voice,connects to the Alexa Voice Service to provide information, news, sports scores, weather, automation and more—instantly and much more With only that one on reboot your thread devices and wait 30-60 minutes. The Sonos can produce more bass, but it more well controlled. Sonos is for sure the better sounding speaker, but HomePods have some really cool conveniences if you’re in the Apple ecosystem. 35 Eve Thread, 61 Hue Zigbee, 32 HomeBridge (4 HKSV) and 3 Somfy TaHoma IO with 76 scenes, 160 automations. supports only Apple Music natively. sounds really great. So basically all homepods are getting updated to os 18 and getting all homepod specific features like enhance audio. Yes it was a joke. Both open source and locally hosted. • 8 mo. mjbirkey1 • 2 yr. Speaker quality: Apple HomePod Mini. I definitely find Apple TV makes the best Home hub. Sep 26, 2019 · Like the HomePod, Google's premium speaker costs $299. Mini is "less smart" and more locked down, but has better privacy For residents of Japan only - if you do not reside in Japan you are welcome to read, but do not post or comment or you will be removed. 1 HomePod, the sound is outstanding and the mini won’t even compare - I would even go to say two won’t compare, but they will be good for stereo pairing. Mar 6, 2023 · Amazon’s Alexa and Google’s Assistant work with either an Android or iPhone, so an Echo or Google Home are interchangeable. Take your pic of what you want. The truth is that the HomePod can't defy the laws of physics. I’m a Apple user on multiple fronts but I do have multiple google Nest Hubs and I am currently testing the redesigned Google Home app on the ‘public preview’ program. The new HomePod second generation definitely fixed this. There's 0 'by the ways' with Siri though. Both are excellent in performance, provided you curb your Other than that they work great. The 2nd though supports the U1 chip and thread and a few other features that I think make it a better choice for the long term. The HomePod Mini is the best choice for Apple users and anyone with Two mini because if you buy one HomePod then a week later you’ll want to buy a second HomePod and you might die broke. Siri/homepod is tolerable. But I quickly realized that in most (>95%) use cases I will be playing stereo through the Apple Music app, and in that case they can’t even do lossless audio. 1” in my 5. Google would be a 2nd choice if you mainly want to ask for information. Index funds. Hi folks, just thought I'd share my experience for people who were like me and were indecisive about which HomePod to buy. To each their own but in my experience with the big three: Google Assistant, Alexa, and Siri - Siri > Google > Alexa. The Sonos One will sound better than a single HPM. Everything is on 16. Technically you can set 2 OG Homepods as default audio output, then go to the menu and add more Homepods/Homepod Minis using the airplay menu. That said, the Google offers bass and treble adjustments so you can customize its sound to your liking. What is involved in converting an existing Google / Nest / Hue home into a Home Assistant home? More specific questions below: upvote · comments Google is far and away the best voice assistant and it’s not even a fair contest between the two. The same applies to Nest Audio; YouTube Music is the go-to service, but you can add others. Hello! Trying to set up a synced speaker system at my house. Any HomePod/ATV/iPad automatically becomes an additional hub for redundancy + range. Good luck. Siri is a bit dumber when asking questions but just as good for timers and setting scenes and such which is basically everything I use her for. The Sonos One currently sells for £199 / $199 / AU$319 on the company’s official store, though we have seen it available for as little as £170 / $170 / $270 at various times from third-party retailers. I use Sonos for music, so I would not need audio capabilities that the bigger HomePod provides. Smart home automation: Google Nest Mini. 747K subscribers in the technews community. Alexa has seemingly gone really down hill in the last couple of years and Google’s keeps getting stronger. Os 18. see if the thread network rebuilds and the troublesome hub recognizes gthe new topology. If you try another streaming service most of them will stream from the HomePod properly. Rakuten Employees: Do not attempt to distribute your referral codes. Now have added 6 HomePod (2023) to my home and it seems to stay stable. If you want to keep listening get the HomePod Mini. Two 100’s probably the same. 99 / AU$79 for the Amazon Echo Dot. These prices will seem like pennies Audio processing can do a lot of things, but it cannot create point sources out of thin air. However, when it comes to Dolby Atmos music, I think soundbar with sub and rear surround is better. 10 mins - 13 mins for the section specifically focusing on music, compared with HomePod G1. HomePods support matter and have integrations with HomeAssistant without needing Nabu casa (although Nabu casa is a great service). I don’t think the surrounds need it too, but I could be mistaken. The sound quality isn't bad, but the real draw is the $99 price tag. While both speakers have a similarly balanced sound profile, the Google speaker has a companion app that lets you EQ its bass and treble and comes with Google Assistant built-in. HomePod is worth it without the lights, I love mine. r/HomeKit. Airplay2 is much more stable than Google Home for multiroom/stereo pairs. 99. The Bose is nice to carry around the house The Apple HomePod mini is a better choice for music and videos than the Google Nest Mini, as its default sound profile is better balanced with a more extended low-bass, and it has a better soundstage performance. If you’re already using Spotify on an iPhone or an iPad (and more recent MacBooks), they can stream to a HomePod. Previous devices are still there. Aug 12, 2021 · at Verizon Wireless. Hence, it sounds impressive when listening close up, at lower volumes or in a small room. HenryACNH. With that said, a pair of HomePods does a good job of creating a virtual surround system and it is probably fine for most people’s needs. Reply. The frustration won’t be worth it. " No, the Homepod doesn't fare well. Feb 21, 2023 · Apple HomePod 2 vs Sonos One: price. 5. Seamless integration. That said, if you're a fan of bass, both the HomePod and the Home Max are worth considering. Alexa has excellent routines and works well with IFTTT and hubs like Hubitat or SmartThings. And what works, USUALLY works almost all of the time. Information & communications technology Technology Jan 15, 2023 · For the HomePod mini, this is a more reasonable price point than its predecessor. Wait till WWDC to buy either. The HomePod also integrates really great in the apple eco system. And this was reaffirmed when we heard the speaker play music against the Sonos One, Google Home Max, and the latest Amazon Echo. For Siri, you can use and iPhone or iWatch. Nest and Echo was the loudest (81dcb). Echo Dot VS Homepod Mini - My Opinion: HOMEPOD is inconsistent. 1) Small enclosure, 2) deep bass, 3) loudness, you can only pick two out of the three. Until Apple allows pairing of more than two HomePods, Sonia will have this advantage. And besides, the One will support Google before long anyway. HomeKit requires a HomeKit hub; either an AppleTV, homepod or ipad. I have two Apple TV's. If you are looking for smart home integration then Alexa is the way to go. You can also link it to an existing google home or Amazon Alexa system and the Beam would work just like a smart assistant. 11n. More detailed comparison. The only thing that I was a smidge disappointed by was the lack of specifics on eARC latency. • 10 mo. Better automations (native iOS geofencing for iPhones; esp useful for multiple people in household) “Hey Siri” works natively for any Apple device turning iPads, iPhones and Macs into transient hubs. No ads or suggestions whatsoever. Thanks. The Nest audio in a stereo pair would be more May 8, 2024 · Both speakers can play virtually any streaming music service you prefer. . Best for the rest. 99 / £49. They don’t behave as “rear surround” speakers but it does work. Google Home -> Apple HomeKit. About the mass market appeal- if you see a Home pod ad on Instagram or Facebook, the majority of people's comments don't get it at all. The 4mm height difference I assume is solely down to the screen being flat instead of concave. HomePod. That said, the Apple has a wider and more spacious-sounding It will crush the home mini by A LOT. Both flake out eqully so no real difference. HomePod (1. I wanted to make this to discuss HomePod software 18 and the information regarding it. I have one in every room in my house. At that point, you can stick one in the kitchen, in a bedroom, even in the bathroom, all for the same price as this "OG 2. If your primary use case is smart home, the minis will be better because they support thread and have UWB (which might enable future use cases around presence detection) and have hidden sensors (which might be enabled in a future software Keep in mind most dorm wifi isn't compatible with devices that require a personal network. WWDC. HomePod mini 100%. The HomePod definitely has more bass than the Sonos pair, if that’s all you care about, but I feel like the bass overpowers the mids and highs and makes everything sound sort of muddy or muffled compared to the Sonos pair. Dec 8, 2020 · The HomePod Mini comes in swinging with an aesthetically pleasing bulb design. 1 system can get much louder. With the first option, no need to be near you HomePod to play, skip, pause your music. 3. That said, Google assistant in terms of the overall experience of interacting with it and the types of questions it can handle is way better than Siri. 747K subscribers in the googlehome community. It takes some time to get it setup, however it is much more robust and allows for nearly everything to connect to it. The difference is built-in support. 4. Mostly because even though Google is way easier to integrate into a smart home and is far better at answering general knowledge queries, we found the microphones on the One to be substantially less sensitive than those on the Homepod. The key differences include: HomePod Mini has better volume control and more drivers, as well as a neodymium magnet. The normal echo is a bit larger. The HomePod Mini consistently has a fuller sound than the Nest Mini. Like the HomePod and Echo Studio, the Google Home Max Echo is more 'fun'. Can play music together or separately than the indoor HomePod. Both Amazon and Google voice assistants are fairly limited when it comes to to the actual automation backends (compared to a real platform like Hubitat, Home Assistant, etc), but Amazon is still light years ahead of Google in this regard. And you can control the HomePod by voice or through your iPhone, your choice, no obligations. The HomeKit hub is being kept on the ATV but the Thread Border Router is moving around all the time and works fine now. Even though it sits with an RRP of £49, a lot of us have gotten used to seeing the Google Nest Mini drop to around £30. Jan 31, 2023 · HomePod mini vs HomePod: Price and availability. When using stereo on the original HomePods, it didn’t allow dialogue or midrange sounds to come out more clear. The speaker even tells me to click its tile, then settings, but there's no settings available aftef clicking on the tile. My 5. Feb 26, 2024 · Our Verdict. Now when the Apple TV is in control everything is more snappier and my cameras respond faster. Live-Eye-885. Additionally the Sonos has “TruePlay” to tune it to your room (use it!) and an EQ to allow you to tweak treble, bass and loudness. I think the 2nd gen can be pretty spotty connection wise. FWIW, I eventually upgraded my single Five to a stereo pair… it’s incredible. I have the Bose SoundLink Color Bluetooth Speaker II Coral Red and two HomePods and three HomePod Minis. For this reason, I would stick with Sonos. Even the 14 pro isn’t getting the new Apple intelligence features which is very unfortunate. 3 with new architecture. Bonus point are that it is compact and nicer to look at on a shelf. As far we can tell, this is the true frequency response of the HomePod. HomePod has 360 audio vs directional on the echo and Nest. Plus, we noticed the Nest Mini tends to blow out at higher volumes. With the HomePod, the music will have texture and depth, while it will sound, by comparison, flat from the stereo pair of standard speakers. They are merely a way for me to communicate to home assistant or allow home assistant to communicate to me. Just terrible. The arc has Dolby Atmos. Join us on discord: bit. He goes into very great detail explaining why, as well as detailing other aspects of what the Homepod is and isn't. Every room is different though, so YMMV. has a 3. hruzthjdlzmhgdfywrxr